Kelty vs Osprey Backpacks

Osprey has the wider range here (31 packs); Osprey starts cheaper at ~$80; the lightest pack of either is the Osprey Daylite Plus at 1.29 lbs. Weights and capacities are the makers' listed specs for the size listed here.

Which brand to buy

Only one of these makers still sells an external-frame pack. The Kelty Trekker 65 at $280 is rated for 50-70 lbs and suits trail crews and scout trips with bulky loads; Osprey has nothing like it. Where the lineups meet is the 55-65 liter internal-frame pack, and there Kelty is the cheaper way in. The Kelty Asher 55 at $169 undercuts the Osprey Rook 65 at $205 by $36, and the Kelty Nena 60 at $180 sits $25 below the women's Osprey Renn 65.

Owners of the cheap end describe similar trades. Asher 55 owners find it most comfortable up to about 30 lbs and accept less refined fabric for an adjustable torso and hipbelt pockets. Rook 65 owners get a suspended mesh back at $205 but name missing hipbelt pockets as their main complaint. Higher up, the Kelty Glendale 65 at $280 carries 30-60 lbs against the Osprey Aether 65 at $370, rated to 60 lbs. Aether owners report comfortable 55-60 lb carries, and Atmos AG 65 owners put that pack's sweet spot at 35-50 lbs, so the $90 pays for heavy-load comfort that owners vouch for, not more rated capacity. The Glendale 65 W adjusts down to a 14 inch torso, which few packs reach. Osprey also covers ground Kelty does not: the Exos 58 at $285 for lightweight trips and daypacks from the Daylite Plus at $80, where Kelty offers only the Asher 35 at $110.

The split follows money and mileage. Kelty's prices and its external frame suit first packs, scout troops and family trips; Osprey earns its premium on heavy carries, lighter long-distance kits and hot-weather days under a ventilated back.

KeltyOsprey
Packs in catalog631
Price range~$110–~$280~$80–~$450
Pack typesTraditional Pack, DaypackDaypack, Traditional Pack, Ultralight Pack
Capacity35–65 L20–70 L
Lightest packKelty Asher 35 (1.75 lbs)Osprey Daylite Plus (1.29 lbs)
Adjustable torso6 of 621 of 31

Kelty vs Osprey: common questions

Is the Kelty Glendale 65 a good alternative to the Osprey Aether 65?▾

For load capacity, yes: the Glendale 65 is rated for 30-60 lbs and the Aether 65 to 60 lbs, at nearly the same weight. The Glendale costs $280 against $370 for the Aether, so the extra money goes on Osprey's sizing and suspension rather than on carrying more.

Does Osprey make an external-frame pack like the Kelty Trekker 65?▾

No. The Kelty Trekker 65 at $280 is the only external-frame pack between the two brands, rated for 50-70 lbs. Osprey's heaviest-load option is the internal-frame Aether Plus 70 at $450.

Which is cheaper for a first backpacking pack, Kelty or Osprey?▾

Kelty. The Asher 55 is $169 and the women's Nena 60 is $180, while Osprey's cheapest full-size packs, the Rook 65 and Renn 65, are $205 each. Asher 55 owners find it comfortable up to about 30 lbs, and Rook 65 owners get a mesh back but miss hipbelt pockets.

Osprey

All Osprey →