REI Co-op Trailmade 60 vs REI Co-op Traverse 35

Quick take: The REI Co-op Trailmade 60 is a traditional pack, has an internal frame and holds 25 L more; the REI Co-op Traverse 35 is a daypack, costs $10 less and is frameless.

Which one to buy

A frame separates these two REI packs far more than the $10 price gap does. The REI Co-op Trailmade 60 is a 60 L backpacking pack on a steel perimeter frame, with an 18-21 in adjustable torso and two hipbelt pockets. The Traverse 35 is a frameless 35 L daypack on a contoured foam pad, one size, with no hipbelt pockets. Yet the Traverse weighs 3.25 lbs, only 0.19 lbs less than the Trailmade's 3.44.

That weight math is the argument. Keep the Traverse around 20 lb, because with no frame anything heavier hangs off your shoulders. The Trailmade's comfort ceiling sits around 35 lb. For overnights, then, the Trailmade carries more, more comfortably, for nearly the same pack weight. It also fits a bear canister, which the Traverse doesn't, and its U-shaped front zip opens like a suitcase, which owners say makes it easy for beginners to pack.

The Traverse earns its place on long days. A 60 L bag is more pack than a day hike needs, and the Traverse's 400D recycled shell over 210D ripstop is tougher cloth for scrambles than the Trailmade's 100D ripstop. It swallows a compact summer overnight kit too, so a hiker who mostly does big days and only sometimes sleeps out gets one pack for both.

Neither breathes well. The Traverse's foam pad carries warm on humid climbs, and the Trailmade's foam panel has no real ventilation channel either. Both leave the rain cover to you. The Trailmade's thin hipbelt padding is the fit detail to check, so load it up in the store before a long trip.

REI Co-op Trailmade 60

For anyone planning real overnights or multi-day trips: it carries more weight on a frame and an adjustable torso, for nearly the same pack weight.

REI Co-op Traverse 35

Best if most of your hiking is long, cold or rough day trips and overnights are rare and light enough to stay around 20 lb.

SpecREI Co-op Trailmade 60REI Co-op Traverse 35
Price$189$179
Rating4.3★ (13)4.7★ (21)
TypeTraditional PackDaypack
Frame TypeInternal FrameFrameless
Capacity60 L35 L
Weight3.44 lbs3.25 lbs
Max Load~40 lbs (tested)Not specified by the manufacturer
Torso Fit18-21 in adjustable, 2 widthsOne size
Material100D ripstop nylon210-denier ripstop nylon with 400-denier recycled nylon shell
Back PanelVentilated foam with steel perimeter frameContoured foam pad
Adjustable torsoYesNo
Ventilated backNoNo
Raincover includedNoNo
Hipbelt pocketsYesNo
Removable lidNoNo
Hydration sleeveYesYes
Fits BV500 bear canYesNo
WarrantyREI satisfaction guarantee: returns within 1 year for members (90 days for non-members); defects in materials or workmanship returnable at any timeREI satisfaction guarantee: returns within 1 year for members (90 days for non-members); defects in materials or workmanship returnable at any time

Pros & cons

REI Co-op Trailmade 60

  • ✓Regularly cited in camping-gear discussions as the best sub-$200 starter pack because the torso, hipbelt, and load lifters all actually adjust.
  • ✓The giant U-shaped front zip opens the pack like a suitcase — beginners rave about how easy packing and finding gear is.
  • ✓Inclusive size runs (including extended hipbelts) fit bodies that mainstream packs ignore.
  • ✓At 3.44 lbs it is lighter than most budget competitors and even some $300 packs.
  • ✓Dual hipbelt pockets, bottle pockets, and a front stuff pouch cover the organization basics without add-ons.
  • ✓REI's return policy effectively lets new backpackers trial it for a season risk-free.
  • ✓Frequent co-op sales push it near $140, at which point owners call it unbeatable.
  • ✓Simple, durable construction with few failure-prone gimmicks — reviews show very low defect rates.
  • ✗The 35 lb comfort ceiling arrives quickly; loaded for a week it sags onto the shoulders in a way step-up packs don't.
  • ✗The foam back panel runs sweaty on climbs — there's no real ventilation channel.
  • ✗No raincover included, and the fabric wets out faster than coated premium cloth.
  • ✗The hipbelt padding is thin, and several reviewers report hot spots on bony hips by day two.
  • ✗No removable lid or top-access flexibility; the design is take-it-or-leave-it simple.
  • ✗The steel perimeter frame is heavier material than the aluminum in pricier packs.
  • ✗Bottle pockets are tight to reach with the pack on.
  • ✗It's a starter pack by design — most owners upgrade within a couple of seasons, so factor resale into the math.

REI Co-op Traverse 35

  • ✓35 L is the largest capacity in this daypack group and genuinely covers a light overnight.
  • ✓A 400D recycled shell over 210D ripstop is a durable combination for the price.
  • ✓$179 undercuts the Osprey Stratos 34 by $36 for 1 L more.
  • ✓REI's return policy and in-store fitting.
  • ✓Recycled content in the main shell fabric.
  • ✓The extra volume suits shoulder-season days when layers bulk up.
  • ✓Contoured foam pad rather than a flat panel.
  • ✓Widely stocked and easy to service or return.
  • ✗52 oz is near the top of the daypack group, heavier than several 55 L backpacking packs.
  • ✗No frame at 35 L, which is a lot of volume to carry on foam alone.
  • ✗REI publishes no maximum load figure.
  • ✗Foam pad construction ventilates poorly on a pack this size.
  • ✗No hipbelt pockets.
  • ✗No rain cover included.
  • ✗At 35 L and this weight, a light backpacking pack may serve better.
  • ✗One size only.

REI Co-op Trailmade 60 vs REI Co-op Traverse 35: common questions

Why buy the Traverse 35 when the Trailmade 60 weighs almost the same?▾

Only if you mostly day hike. The Traverse has tougher 400D shell fabric and a size that suits a day's gear, but it has no frame, so keep it around 20 lb. For overnights the framed Trailmade carries far better.

Can the Traverse 35 replace the Trailmade 60 for a weekend trip?▾

For a compact summer kit, yes. Without a frame or hipbelt pockets, though, it gets uncomfortable as the load grows, and it isn't built around a bear canister. The Trailmade, which stays comfortable to around 35 lb, is the safer weekend pack.

Which of the two runs cooler on a hot climb?▾

Neither does well. The Traverse's contoured foam carries warm on humid climbs, and the Trailmade's foam panel has no real ventilation channel. If a cool back is a priority, look beyond this pair.

Similar backpacks

Kelty Nena 60
~$180
Traditional Pack

Kelty's women's-specific budget backpacking pack is the Nena 60: a perimeter frame, an AMP-Flow ventilated back and an adjustable 15.5-21 in torso for $180. Kelty rates it for 40-60 lb, the same ceiling as the $280 Glendale, at 3.31 lb. It is a top-loader with a sleeping-bag compartment and a centre hydration port.

60 L3.31 lbs40-60 lb Carry RangeVentilated back

Weight

3.31 lbs

Capacity

60 L

Frame

Internal Frame

Best for: Women on a budget carrying 40-60 lb on multi-day trips
Six Moon Designs Wy'east Daypack
~$185
Daypack

Six Moon Designs makes only one daypack, the Wy'east: 34 L in 210D Robic at 20 oz, with a removable hydration sleeve (1.3 oz) and removable hipbelt (1.7 oz) both included in that figure. The EVA foam back pad doubles as a sit pad. It is sold in one size, in Robic at $185 or X-Pac VX21 at $280.

34 L1.25 lbsHydration Sleeve

Weight

1.25 lbs

Capacity

34 L

Frame

Frameless

Best for: Long day hikes and summer overnights where a 20 lb load is enough
Kelty Asher 55
~$170
Traditional Pack
4.6(7)

The Asher is Kelty's value backpacking pack. At $170 and 3 lb 2 oz it undercuts everything with comparable capacity, and reviewers consistently place it as the budget pick.

55 L3.13 lbsFIT-Pro TorsoVentilated back

Weight

3.13 lbs

Capacity

55 L

Frame

Internal Frame

Also in 65 L / 85 L

Best for: Budget backpackers whose loads stay around 30 lb